Selling Your Business When You and Your Partner Disagree

/ Business Insight

If you want to sell your business and your partner does not, start with what each of you needs, then compare an outside sale with a possible partner buyout. Review your ownership agreements and the business's financial position with your advisors. Price matters, but so do payment timing, financing, and the risks each of you would keep.

You may feel ready to retire while your partner sees years of growth ahead. After working together for so long, it can be hard to say that your plans have changed. You can respect what you have built together and still be honest about wanting something different for yourself.

Say what you need from an exit

Write down why you want an exit: retirement, less responsibility, or a complete break. Your plans may also change because of your illness or your partner's. Acknowledge that respectfully, protect private information, and discuss who can keep the business running while you consider the options.

Look beyond the terms to the relationship. You may agree on an exit and want to preserve a friendship, or years of frustration may make every discussion difficult. IMG can help you understand the concerns behind each position and adapt the negotiation approach to the situation. A different transition period, clearer financial information, or agreed communication rules may give you a more productive starting point.

Understand what your agreements allow

Ask your attorney to review the relevant operating, partnership, shareholder, or buy-sell agreements. You need to know who can approve buyer outreach, what a sale requires, and whether restrictions or agreed valuation procedures apply. Do not assume your ownership percentage gives you every decision-making right.

Agreeing to explore a sale is different from agreeing to accept an offer. If you and your partner disagree about your legal rights, address that before telling buyers the business is for sale. You may each need independent advice if your interests conflict.

Understand price, proceeds, and risk

It is frustrating to discuss price when you and your partner are using different numbers. Ask an advisor to explain what each estimate includes, what information supports it, and whether it values the whole business or one person's ownership interest. Make sure you are comparing the same thing.

Then ask your financial and tax advisors to explain how debt, expenses, taxes, and payment timing could affect your proceeds. If you need cash at closing, an offer that pays over time may not meet your needs, even if the headline price looks attractive.

Write down what you both accept and what still needs checking. You do not have to agree on a price before you understand how it would affect each of you.

Structure a partner buyout, not just a price

A partner buyout can be amicable or contentious. Even when you agree that one of you should leave, you may need help with price, payments, and responsibilities. When trust is strained, those same questions can feel personal. IMG helps owners work through the relationship nuances and commercial terms without assuming every partnership needs the same approach. Compare a buyout with an outside sale, a later exit, or stepping back from management, taking account of your agreements, funding, and personal goals.

If your partner buys you out, discuss cash at closing versus payments over time, where the funding comes from, and whether the business can support the payments. With your attorney and financial advisors, examine security, guarantees, missed-payment remedies, and remaining obligations. The structure should reflect both value and risk, not simply make a headline number easier to accept.

Agree on how you will work through the sale

If you decide to explore a sale together, agree on a few working rules before contacting buyers:

  • Who will speak with the advisor and keep every owner informed.
  • Who must approve sharing financial details and other sensitive information.
  • How you will compare offers and address disagreements.
  • Which decisions each owner must still approve, even if one person coordinates the process.

Keep a written record of decisions. Having one point of contact can make communication easier, but it does not give that person authority they do not otherwise have.

Keep your foot on the gas through closing

An accepted offer is not the finish line. Keep serving customers, managing your team, pursuing sales, and watching cash flow throughout due diligence and right up to closing. Agree who handles buyer requests so the transaction does not take over daily operations. If performance slips, a buyer may seek a lower price or pause the process. Strong operations reduce that risk, but cannot guarantee the original terms will hold.

At IMG, we help owners sell their businesses, navigate M&A, and negotiate deal terms. Our Deal & Partnership Negotiation service also supports partner buyouts and transactions where buyer and seller are already connected. Michael Givner leads the work directly, with valuation informing the economics. Contact us to discuss a workable structure while your attorney and other specialists address legal, tax, and financing matters.

General information only. Obtain advice specific to your legal, tax, and financial circumstances.